{"apiVersion":"1.0.0","budgetVersion":{"slug":"ppb2027","display_name":"Proposed UN Programme Budget for 2027, Peacekeeping Budget for 2026/2027 and Plan Outline 2026-2028","ppb_year":2027,"is_default":true,"sort_order":0},"coverage":["Budget citations describe recorded programme-budget references, not legal in-force status.","Missing extracted text does not establish that the original document contains no relevant provisions.","Resolution collections are related documents, not necessarily ordered versions or legal replacements.","Citation context is the selected budget cycle. Extraction and relationship coverage may be incomplete."],"document":{"symbol":"A/RES/73/203","title":"Identification of Customary International Law","issuingBody":"GA","year":2019,"documentType":"Resolutions","subjects":["Customary International Law"],"agendaItems":{"numbers":["82"],"titles":["Report of the International Law Commission on the work of its 70th session."]},"sourceUrl":"https://documents.un.org/api/symbol/access?s=A%2FRES%2F73%2F203&l=en&t=pdf","pageUrl":"https://mandates.un.org/mandate/A/RES/73/203?ppb_version=ppb2027","canonicalUrl":"https://mandates.un.org/mandate/A/RES/73/203","jsonUrl":"https://mandates.un.org/mandate/A/RES/73/203.json?ppb_version=ppb2027","budgetVersion":"ppb2027","matchingCitationCount":0,"matchingEntityCount":0,"matchingEntities":[],"matchingFoundationalEntities":[],"matchingProgrammes":[],"matchingBudgetLocations":[],"series":null,"group":null,"details":{"status":"included","citations":[],"budgetLocations":[],"foundationalEntities":[],"budgetLocationExpenditures":[],"entityCitationTotals":{},"entityExpenditures":{},"paragraphs":{"status":"available","language":"en","items":[{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"67f279aa-8477-584f-8512-44e1e04b5569","position":0,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Seventy-third session","type":"frontmatter","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"b83113fc-8c37-5c8f-9fcb-fee8e30ae60d","position":1,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Agenda item 82","type":"frontmatter","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"7ddf27d6-35a4-5bb3-8e5a-41f275e9df3b","position":2,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 20 December 2018","type":"frontmatter","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"04fde717-0ae1-5a45-9565-355fb48b4cf2","position":3,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"[on the report of the Sixth Committee (A/73/556)]","type":"frontmatter","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[["A/73/556","https://undocs.org/A/73/556"]],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"bb8dd5fe-70db-5b10-8e5b-2710d08f3876","position":4,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Identification of customary international law","type":"title","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":"73/203.","links":[],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"f3c1c13f-0922-5648-bd66-06c8b110b1ab","position":5,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The General Assembly,","type":"opening","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":0,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"6e7b494f-669c-5139-bad8-7fb94d986f27","position":6,"note_ids":[1],"note_references":[{"offset":116,"note_id":1}],"text":"Having considered chapter V of the report of the International Law Commission on the work of its seventieth session, which contains the draft conclusions on identification of customary international law,","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Having considered* chapter V of the report of the International Law Commission on the work of its seventieth session, which contains the draft conclusions on identification of customary international law,","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Having considered","action_verb_normalized":"consider","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"8d863169-841b-5429-bc6f-ca4aee16d32e","position":7,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Taking note of the recommendation of the International Law Commission contained in paragraph 63 of its report,","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Taking note* of the recommendation of the International Law Commission contained in paragraph 63 of its report,","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Taking note","action_verb_normalized":"take note","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"9f641d1c-ac2e-5bd8-80b3-9cd51ca4ec0e","position":8,"note_ids":[2],"note_references":[{"offset":255,"note_id":2}],"text":"Noting the memorandum by the Secretariat on ways and means for making the evidence of customary international law more readily available, which surveys the present state of evidence of customary international law and makes suggestions for its improvement,","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Noting* the memorandum by the Secretariat on ways and means for making the evidence of customary international law more readily available, which surveys the present state of evidence of customary international law and makes suggestions for its improvement,","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Noting","action_verb_normalized":"note","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"e21c16d0-c502-5a52-b26e-637e43c4894f","position":9,"note_ids":[3],"note_references":[{"offset":79,"note_id":3}],"text":"Noting also the bibliography on the subject prepared by the Special Rapporteur,","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Noting* also the bibliography on the subject prepared by the Special Rapporteur,","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Noting","action_verb_normalized":"note","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"4b614d09-c420-5b5e-9f2c-7e029504658d","position":10,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Emphasizing the continuing importance of the codification and progressive development of international law, as referred to in Article 13, paragraph 1 (a), of the Charter of the United Nations,","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Emphasizing* the continuing importance of the codification and progressive development of international law, as referred to in Article 13, paragraph 1 (a), of the Charter of the United Nations,","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Emphasizing","action_verb_normalized":"emphasize","action_verb_type":"reinforcing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"fa07c20d-46f0-5efe-b5ce-878c3dafe5ec","position":11,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Noting that the subject of identification of customary international law is of major importance in international relations,","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"preambular","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Noting* that the subject of identification of customary international law is of major importance in international relations,","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Noting","action_verb_normalized":"note","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"06368493-3626-56ec-ae3e-168324c3148c","position":12,"note_ids":[4],"note_references":[{"offset":188,"note_id":4}],"text":"Welcomes the conclusion of the work of the International Law Commission on identification of customary international law and its adoption of the draft conclusions and commentaries thereto;","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"operative","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Welcomes* the conclusion of the work of the International Law Commission on identification of customary international law and its adoption of the draft conclusions and commentaries thereto;","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Welcomes","action_verb_normalized":"welcome","action_verb_type":"evaluative","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"898b84f9-765b-57cb-bfe5-a0a6f6752300","position":13,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Expresses its appreciation to the International Law Commission for its continuing contribution to the codification and progressive development of international law;","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"operative","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Expresses* its appreciation to the International Law Commission for its continuing contribution to the codification and progressive development of international law;","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Expresses","action_verb_normalized":"appreciate","action_verb_type":"evaluative","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"3a616601-1e6a-57d7-9184-ab6774f984ba","position":14,"note_ids":[5],"note_references":[{"offset":142,"note_id":5}],"text":"Takes note of the statements in the Sixth Committee on the subject, including those made at the seventy-third session of the General Assembly, after the International Law Commission had completed its consideration of this topic in accordance with its statute;","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"operative","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"3.","links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Takes note* of the statements in the Sixth Committee on the subject, including those made at the seventy-third session of the General Assembly, after the International Law Commission had completed its consideration of this topic in accordance with its statute;","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Takes note","action_verb_normalized":"take note","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"ec5e787a-3f15-5da1-ba4f-08579dab749f","position":15,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Also takes note of the conclusions on identification of customary international law, the text of which is annexed to the present resolution, with the commentaries thereto, brings them to the attention of States and all who may be called upon to identify rules of customary international law, and encourages their widest possible dissemination;","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"operative","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"4.","links":[],"textWithHighlights":"Also *takes note* of the conclusions on identification of customary international law, the text of which is annexed to the present resolution, with the commentaries thereto, brings them to the attention of States and all who may be called upon to identify rules of customary international law, and encourages their widest possible dissemination;","mandates":[{"action_verb":"takes note","action_verb_normalized":"take note","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"e9291d41-de68-55b5-9a09-a19987ceb7db","position":16,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Acknowledges the utility of published digests and surveys of practice relating to international law, including those that make legislative, executive and judicial practice widely available, and encourages States to make every effort to support existing publications and libraries specialized in international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":"operative","paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"5.","links":[],"textWithHighlights":"*Acknowledges* the utility of published digests and surveys of practice relating to international law, including those that make legislative, executive and judicial practice widely available, and encourages States to make every effort to support existing publications and libraries specialized in international law.","mandates":[{"action_verb":"Acknowledges","action_verb_normalized":"acknowledge","action_verb_type":"observing","assignees":[],"mentioned_entities":[],"deliverables":[]}],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"9d543a1b-4ae0-56d9-89cf-f5e3a7f9e459","position":17,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"62nd plenary meeting 20 December 2018","type":"signature","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"main","text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"1c24d354-7125-518b-ba30-46e9029b0473","position":18,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Identification of customary international law","type":"heading","heading_level":1,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":"Annex","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"subtype":"annex","parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"a0bf1b57-523e-5e11-b559-9b182ae19e94","position":19,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part One","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"c523971c-00b0-54a1-8d5d-2bb5853ec96f","position":20,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Introduction","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"eb38ea3c-9608-5aca-bf64-2fe29059b9dd","position":21,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 1","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"110c9896-3469-5222-8e1f-254d30828286","position":22,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Scope","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"6e60b0bc-29b7-5894-ad98-16c2233b37f4","position":23,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The present conclusions concern the way in which the existence and content of rules of customary international law are to be determined.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"b1b36d26-72fc-51bf-8559-5ce352a0dd58","position":24,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part Two","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"b9a62f33-b47c-5854-b625-2d2f17956313","position":25,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Basic approach","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"0a84f4cf-3cb5-52cb-9884-e80834eeac35","position":26,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 2","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"70861354-6f13-5a23-9391-dda8df37d700","position":27,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Two constituent elements","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"dafff15d-336d-5a1f-b622-ed696f59d381","position":28,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"To determine the existence and content of a rule of customary international law, it is necessary to ascertain whether there is a general practice that is accepted as law (opinio juris).","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"06b1825a-d311-5d71-9c14-dc95195594ad","position":29,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 3","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"8ea91c20-9749-53a8-bd30-1f66c00ce394","position":30,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Assessment of evidence for the two constituent elements","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"be3e82ba-f44b-59ca-bcfd-7980bbaf2910","position":31,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"In assessing evidence for the purpose of ascertaining whether there is a general practice and whether that practice is accepted as law (opinio juris), regard must be had to the overall context, the nature of the rule, and the particular circumstances in which the evidence in question is to be found.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"2c2769d6-65b3-594a-b5ec-892c9a937e91","position":32,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Each of the two constituent elements is to be separately ascertained. This requires an assessment of evidence for each element.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"e7e2f0e8-56d8-59b1-8891-d48818e71415","position":33,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part Three","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"fed61961-3f26-5362-b602-e1f1fb2b2e80","position":34,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A general practice","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"c9222c34-5999-5ebc-bf21-261985f2fb84","position":35,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 4","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"757289d6-42a3-57fb-ba08-0dc6165967a5","position":36,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Requirement of practice","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"f32158d7-f989-5f50-bbcf-aa079cdd14eb","position":37,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The requirement of a general practice, as a constituent element of customary international law, refers primarily to the practice of States that contributes to the formation, or expression, of rules of customary international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"5473bcb8-734d-5a50-b5f7-f027964e12a0","position":38,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"In certain cases, the practice of international organizations also contributes to the formation, or expression, of rules of customary international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"8ee50eb8-3790-529e-bea9-a92cfdc8a138","position":39,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conduct of other actors is not practice that contributes to the formation, or expression, of rules of customary international law, but may be relevant when assessing the practice referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"3.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"7528f411-0685-5588-a23c-897846287c32","position":40,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 5","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"a64556e8-73a5-5b67-a05b-bf71f7df5c2e","position":41,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conduct of the State as State practice","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"13f6c697-b50e-5cbb-a05b-a8d75646ac57","position":42,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"State practice consists of conduct of the State, whether in the exercise of its executive, legislative, judicial or other functions.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"cd264c24-dca0-55e3-ba95-6970f1412bec","position":43,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 6","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"e09b3d68-30c0-5b58-8008-d8f1d89aa68f","position":44,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Forms of practice","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"1d5aacbf-ef81-5570-aeba-bf334c3e7fac","position":45,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Practice may take a wide range of forms. It includes both physical and verbal acts. It may, under certain circumstances, include inaction.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"bf1a9bc7-4a42-5b1f-a2f0-a0fcba3d0dd1","position":46,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Forms of State practice include, but are not limited to: diplomatic acts and correspondence; conduct in connection with resolutions adopted by an international organization or at an intergovernmental conference; conduct in connection with treaties; executive conduct, including operational conduct “on the ground”; legislative and administrative acts; and decisions of national courts.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"d4fb7f39-3748-5afe-aef8-97164c61ef0c","position":47,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"There is no predetermined hierarchy among the various forms of practice.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"3.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"2b50886f-46ae-5fe7-a36e-5797593cfeb5","position":48,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 7","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"98c5f6a1-3cbb-5904-8a70-5b2138b13adc","position":49,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Assessing a State’s practice","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"86d04854-1618-5936-8fd2-da23259346e9","position":50,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Account is to be taken of all available practice of a particular State, which is to be assessed as a whole.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"956384c6-e382-563c-92be-c22d39f79cb9","position":51,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Where the practice of a particular State varies, the weight to be given to that practice may, depending on the circumstances, be reduced.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"493bfc4d-859b-5a5d-b0b6-4027b3e5f276","position":52,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 8","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"ed173a5c-91a2-547a-995e-0a3db37f50eb","position":53,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The practice must be general","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"7191b5a8-b140-5505-a1de-32a2d79e4533","position":54,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The relevant practice must be general, meaning that it must be sufficiently widespread and representative, as well as consistent.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"92b4f9aa-472f-5c4f-9d20-f9a791969aa6","position":55,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Provided that the practice is general, no particular duration is required.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"95f320b6-e11b-5add-90df-45e164734f5c","position":56,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part Four","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"674e1902-1061-59d1-b97b-78d4f0a1c0f1","position":57,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Accepted as law (opinio juris)","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"a15283b4-d419-576d-b29c-bbbeedd23c7c","position":58,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 9","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"1e568b4f-0a2a-5d53-91b0-d137593bc571","position":59,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Requirement of acceptance as law (opinio juris)","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"2b7839ab-bd63-557c-9eec-630db9b22056","position":60,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The requirement, as a constituent element of customary international law, that the general practice be accepted as law (opinio juris) means that the practice in question must be undertaken with a sense of legal right or obligation.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"4cf32729-83b8-5247-9dad-0ef6443c44dc","position":61,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A general practice that is accepted as law (opinio juris) is to be distinguished from mere usage or habit.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"84523002-680b-5631-9f35-03d423d9908c","position":62,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 10","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"0921e5e9-d9b3-533a-b7ad-253b1fcc0f31","position":63,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Forms of evidence of acceptance as law (opinio juris)","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"4b59a6e1-d182-57e9-ba4a-b4943a05d64f","position":64,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Evidence of acceptance as law (opinio juris) may take a wide range of forms.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"09d9220f-1bb0-5834-b4d6-81668f3d06b9","position":65,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Forms of evidence of acceptance as law (opinio juris) include, but are not limited to: public statements made on behalf of States; official publications; government legal opinions; diplomatic correspondence; decisions of national courts; treaty provisions; and conduct in connection with resolutions adopted by an international organization or at an intergovernmental conference.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"41dfe162-d844-5117-adfe-bfe808453d28","position":66,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Failure to react over time to a practice may serve as evidence of acceptance as law (opinio juris), provided that States were in a position to react and the circumstances called for some reaction.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"3.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"86b59eaa-7478-5055-8aba-0473c41d0feb","position":67,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part Five","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"91409fcb-0204-5fd7-aec3-1b46f864c106","position":68,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Significance of certain materials for the identification of customary international law","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"7a517970-2239-5a8b-a099-a800292a6765","position":69,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 11","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"327e265f-9bd2-58ba-9a45-0f876b589de2","position":70,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Treaties","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"92aac352-ef9a-5a53-b7e1-1dd226ece5e3","position":71,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A rule set forth in a treaty may reflect a rule of customary international law if it is established that the treaty rule:","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"ba4d9b39-aa9f-5fcd-b776-7f1913cbe09b","position":72,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"codified a rule of customary international law existing at the time when the treaty was concluded;","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":2,"prefix":"(a)","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"e53b3f32-aa1d-556c-ab58-75a207a151c1","position":73,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"has led to the crystallization of a rule of customary international law that had started to emerge prior to the conclusion of the treaty; or","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":2,"prefix":"(b)","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"0b53a06a-f296-56ef-8dd9-e8cf9dde2fe8","position":74,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"has given rise to a general practice that is accepted as law (opinio juris), thus generating a new rule of customary international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":2,"prefix":"(c)","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"aae87e93-a515-52e0-b96b-555901fab887","position":75,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The fact that a rule is set forth in a number of treaties may, but does not necessarily, indicate that the treaty rule reflects a rule of customary international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"0a2bc53c-da52-570e-837b-19e460d5ed93","position":76,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 12","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"668e23b6-2a31-58eb-bcc8-0b95e75b04bb","position":77,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Resolutions of international organizations and intergovernmental conferences","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"83bfab89-6b0d-5abd-849b-3911d59dd64a","position":78,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A resolution adopted by an international organization or at an intergovernmental conference cannot, of itself, create a rule of customary international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"20525829-ba79-56d7-9535-2668a14d4b5c","position":79,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A resolution adopted by an international organization or at an intergovernmental conference may provide evidence for determining the existence and content of a rule of customary international law, or contribute to its development.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"574b254c-f6a1-50da-aab5-0bcd95859c0f","position":80,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A provision in a resolution adopted by an international organization or at an intergovernmental conference may reflect a rule of customary international law if it is established that the provision corresponds to a general practice that is accepted as law (opinio juris).","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"3.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"7f3ce308-eb2c-5557-8650-ee2c6b63cc35","position":81,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 13","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"58a15acc-9fe0-589c-84ac-dd20a2113dfe","position":82,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Decisions of courts and tribunals","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"0004c661-3d75-5e1b-b3b7-1193dab64b55","position":83,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Decisions of international courts and tribunals, in particular of the International Court of Justice, concerning the existence and content of rules of customary international law are a subsidiary means for the determination of such rules.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"1fd85019-6c6e-5b6c-bd9d-7121938f8526","position":84,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Regard may be had, as appropriate, to decisions of national courts concerning the existence and content of rules of customary international law, as a subsidiary means for the determination of such rules.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"1b03e4c4-270a-5b33-89a9-807792fa744b","position":85,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 14","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"1055ba08-4f06-5455-b412-f7b351ed6fb6","position":86,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Teachings","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"aa7d1f21-b0b0-5932-8029-bf2b025abdbc","position":87,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Teachings of the most highly qualified publicists of the various nations may serve as a subsidiary means for the determination of rules of customary international law.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"7c616d96-76f1-534a-8ced-338692084ca1","position":88,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part Six","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"3c2a7e66-d347-5083-acdc-a7dcaa3681b3","position":89,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Persistent objector","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"e7bba941-a3f2-5415-baa8-5e2710bb6488","position":90,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 15","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"bf9057d5-2f4d-5dcf-9000-045248dbf0f4","position":91,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Persistent objector","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"b0bd318c-cc2d-5deb-91b9-cf34537a4222","position":92,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Where a State has objected to a rule of customary international law while that rule was in the process of formation, the rule is not opposable to the State concerned for so long as it maintains its objection.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"a9fe0468-27b1-563b-81da-c9b09daffc5a","position":93,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The objection must be clearly expressed, made known to other States, and maintained persistently.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"9919ccc3-fe8e-5618-9332-f535cd0df7e7","position":94,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"The present conclusion is without prejudice to any question concerning peremptory norms of general international law (jus cogens).","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"3.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"9f69803b-d6d9-58df-8531-ead161a4a6b7","position":95,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Part Seven","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"3339aba2-0064-5700-8f08-ce5e6faf2daa","position":96,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Particular customary international law","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"50339652-ee1b-5f87-978f-45070a1a30ad","position":97,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Conclusion 16","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"30885976-b582-54c9-a8e7-e432d2e2caf0","position":98,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"Particular customary international law","type":"heading","heading_level":2,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"113b08aa-02d0-52d8-910f-9693e398c94c","position":99,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"A rule of particular customary international law, whether regional, local or other, is a rule of customary international law that applies only among a limited number of States.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"1.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"fb3bc986-8e6b-54e7-b45f-65a3a5de87f3","position":100,"note_ids":[],"note_references":[],"text":"To determine the existence and content of a rule of particular customary international law, it is necessary to ascertain whether there is a general practice among the States concerned that is accepted by them as law (opinio juris) among themselves.","type":"paragraph","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":1,"prefix":"2.","links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"af14b272-8f34-5c79-a75c-6e03fcc4808a","position":101,"note_ids":[1],"note_references":[],"text":"Official Records of the General Assembly, Seventy-third Session, Supplement No. 10 (A/73/10).","type":"footnote","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"d480619c-1335-58f0-a9b4-61b2ce15d78f","position":102,"note_ids":[2],"note_references":[],"text":"A/CN.4/710.","type":"footnote","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"19fc2e4c-1105-5b7c-9095-e78f8662ffca","position":103,"note_ids":[3],"note_references":[],"text":"A/CN.4/717/Add.1.","type":"footnote","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"daf8d087-026e-524c-89c8-7fad8ad3e968","position":104,"note_ids":[4],"note_references":[],"text":"Official Records of the General Assembly, Seventy-third Session, Supplement No. 10 (A/73/10), para. 66.","type":"footnote","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"},{"extraction_quality_warning":false,"id":"8b778f9e-d8a8-5e8b-b94c-048d07a78d64","position":105,"note_ids":[5],"note_references":[],"text":"See A/C.6/73/SR.20, A/C.6/73/SR.21, A/C.6/73/SR.22, A/C.6/73/SR.23, A/C.6/73/SR.24 and A/C.6/73/SR.29; see also the statements in the Sixth Committee that are available on the United Nations PaperSmart portal.","type":"footnote","heading_level":null,"paragraph_type":null,"paragraph_level":null,"prefix":null,"links":[],"section":"annex","annex_index":1,"text_index":1,"parser_version":"sem-v5","source":"digitallibrary"}]},"versionHistory":null,"reports":{"status":"included","data":{"source":"union","data":{"pageOneAccepted":true,"reports":[]}}},"relatedDocuments":{"status":"not_included"}}}}